Bushfire ‘risk landscape’ forum in Castlemaine

This forum–focussing on the West Central district–was held in Castlemaine on December 11 for a disappointing attendance of only 8 community members, outnumbered by DEPI officers. The West Central district covers the area from Geelong to north of Bendigo, and from west Melbourne to Avoca.

 

The forum appears to be part of an effort by DEPI to communicate its efforts to get a more precise understanding of the effects of fire on the community and the environment.

Wewak track, Castlemaine Diggings NHP: draft environmental scan contradicts itself on the matter of the 'fire dependence' of our forests.

Wewak track, Castlemaine Diggings NHP: the draft environmental scan contradicts itself on the matter of the ‘fire dependence’ of our forests.

 

The information tabled at the meeting seemed heavily dependent on computer modelling. Questions were asked at the forum about ‘ground truthing’ of this modelling, and community representatives present were unconvinced by the answers.

 

Participants at the forum were presented with a draft environmental scan of the area which outlined the challenges and complexities of fire management. This document confirmed what we have often commented on: that DEPI confronts serious contradictory demands in its fire program. One example: winery owners prefer spring burning to autumn burning, because of the risk of smoke taint to grapes. Ecologists and apiarists dislike spring fire because it interrupts flowering and breeding processes. Unfortunately DEPI too often resorts to glib phrases like ‘trade offs’ to explain its activities, which more often than not sacrifice the environment for economic activity. Conservation organisations have consistently hammered the idea that we should aim for a better result for everyone—for example, by more detailed management of much smaller burns.

 

The evidence is piling up that the crude target of burning five per cent of public land every year [no matter how much land is burned in bushfires] is environmentally damaging and does not improve public safety. For that reason any process that contributes to a clearer understanding of the issues is good.

 

There were, however, a few unsettling blips in the info presented at the forum. A map on page 11 of the draft environmental scan shows that forests in the Mount Alexander region are ‘fire dependent’. This is NOT the case—as the text of the same document points out on page 9. Further, the scan appears to blandly accept the continuing development of housing in dangerous areas (page 20). This is not a simple matter, and the draft tells us that ‘new land use criteria will be developed as a result of the Bushfires Royal Commission.’ In our opinion these criteria are already overdue.

 

The forum was part of a process leading to the planned release of a new strategic bushfire plan by June 30 2014.

 

Posted in Fire Management, News | Comments Off on Bushfire ‘risk landscape’ forum in Castlemaine

Ecology last?

The Castlemaine Forum was given a summary of the bushfire risk profile developed by DEPI in cooperation with various research bodies. The profile is a working document rather than a set of conclusions, and is about risk to human life and assets: no way has yet been developed in this system of assessing risk to the environment in current burning practices [p 7]. 

According to DEPI computer modelling, risk to people and property has been reduced by 40% since 2002 by a combination of major bushfires [mainly] and controlled burning. The report adds:

Continue reading →

Posted in Fire Management, News | Comments Off on Ecology last?

Quotable quote

From DEPI’s Risk profiles report, page 30:

‘Fuel reduction is much more effective in some areas than others in reducing overall bushfire risk [to life and safety].’

This common sense observation is yet another dig at the five per cent policy, which involves burning everywhere, regardless of the value to human safety.

Posted in Fire Management | Comments Off on Quotable quote

Moss guide published

moss-pic-for-webFOBIF’s publication, A field guide to the mosses of south eastern Australia, has been published. If you wish to place an order this form has all the details and includes a sample page.

Posted in News | Comments Off on Moss guide published

Fire: what the research is saying…and not saying–yet

FOBIF has just received the Box-Ironbark Experimental Mosaic Burning Project_Newsletter 5, on research conducted in the Heathcote-Rushworth forest. The newsletter documents important features of forest structure, like the presence of large trees, and the quality of ground cover. It’s a brief and interesting document. Its interest lies, however, in what it doesn’t say, rather than what it does.

The newsletter points out something we all know: that box ironbark forests are highly  modified by past practices, and that ‘important structural features’ like large trees, and deep leaf litter are ‘exceedingly rare.’ The research documents this in painstaking detail.

So: it’s ‘important to know how planned burns may further alter forest structure, and what effect they may have on already limited forest resources.’ Work is under way to ‘compare pre and post fire data’ , and the results will be detailed in future newsletters.

We can’t offer comments on the forests over at Heathcote-Graytown, but here are a few comments on the matters raised by the Project:

–Almost every prescribed burn we’ve examined in our area has destroyed some of the ‘exceedingly rare’ large trees in the relevant zone.

–Deep leaf litter is a problem: for ecologists it’s an important feature of forest health. For fire managers, it’s just fuel.

The moral of this seems to be that fuel reduction burns are definitely bad for forest structure, unless they’re done in very small patches, with painstaking attention to detail [impossible under the present regime, where managers are compelled to burn large areas to get up to the five per cent].

One further point: the researchers might want to compare their findings with past Departmental burn plans. These are supposed to record the effects of prescribed burns on the very things the researchers are looking at [see page 40 of the 2006 Code of Practice, for example. The 1995 Code is a bit vaguer, it also requires monitoring and research into particular burns]. They might find this material hard to find, however: we’ve never succeeded in getting access to it.

 

Posted in Fire Management | 1 Comment